Carnal Knowledge is clearly Mike Nichols' best film. It sets out to tell us certain things about these few characters and their sexual crucifixions, and it succeeds.
More than any other film Nichols has made, Carnal Knowledge reminds me of his stage work at its best, particularly of the highly stylized Luv in which low comedy techniques were employed to illuminate material that might otherwise seem too cruel, or too anti‐heroic for a dramatic medium.
90
TV Guide Magazine
TV Guide Magazine
An uneven but unusually thoughtful melodrama, Carnal Knowledge avoids most of the the trendy excesses that make some other films of its era so difficult to watch today.
90
Village VoiceAndrew Sarris
Village VoiceAndrew Sarris
Carnal Knowledge is a movie that almost lives up to it's brilliant title. [08 Jul 1971, p.34]
60
The New YorkerPauline Kael
The New YorkerPauline Kael
As Mike Nichols has directed the material, the effects are almost all achieved through the line readings, and the cleverness is unpleasant -- it's all surface and whacking emphasis.
50
Chicago ReaderDave Kehr
Chicago ReaderDave Kehr
The picture has its moments of chilling insight, though essentially it is one more quaint early-70s stab at an American art cinema that never materialized.
Mike Nichols' Carnal Knowlede is a rather superficial and limited probe of American male sexual hypocrisies.
50
Time Out
Time Out
As a slice of familiar Feiffer cynicism, tracing the arid sex life of two contrasting males from eager college days to drained middle age, this was never quite the major assault on sexism and male chauvinism it set itself up to be.